Wednesday, 4 March 2015

Analysing Game Reviews - LO1


Tomb Raider


Reviewers Impression
The reviewer, Keza Macdonald (from IGN), enjoyed the intelligent design of the action-adventure game, Tomb Raider. She said that the multiplayer has good combat mechanics in context to the single-player mode, but that it is not flexible or varied enough to support a multiplayer mode. When tomb raider becomes cliche the player doesn't mind because of the breathlessly exiting graphics of the game.

Suggestions for Improvements
The reviewer said that the game was hugely exiting, had amazing graphics, great characterisation and provided amazing core gameplay throughout the story mode. However, they said that the multiplayer was letting the game down. The multiplayer didn't have the same feel of survival which was implemented into the story mode. They multiplayer was less objective based and didn't involve any form of problem solving, instead it focused on the combat with standard modes such as team game like team-deathmatch.

The Verdict
She said that "Tomb Raider is well written, sympathetic, exiting, beautiful and well-made." The game has lots of action which is in a similar style to Nathan Drake from the Uncharted series. The reviewer believes tha from playing the game they have been able to understand more about the character of Lara Croft than when playing previous games from the Tomb Raider series. She said that she enjoyed the graphic detail of the game as well as the gameplay because it allowed for exiting situations with the entertaining combat system which has been implemented into the game. The player is able to use a range of weapons which are stored in their inventory and are always at their disposal. They have the ability to become more armored as they progress through the game in order to make the challenges easier to survive as the enemies within the game become harder to defeat and grow in numbers. For these reasons the reviewer provided the game a rating of 9.1/10.


The Last of Us


Reviewers Impression
The reviewer, Collin Moriarty (from IGN), enjoyed the narrative and graphics of the game. He said that the game did a wonderful job of creating varied environments and a compelling story which clearly explained who all of the characters were, and made the player involved in the game with them. The game sets the scene but also produces the gameplay which allows the player to be endeared into the evolving relationship bewteen Joel and Ellie, the two protagonists. He said that there are a range of items which the player can access and that it can be incredibly unpredictable when you will need them.

Suggestions for Improvements
Collin Moriarty has not provided any improvements for the game which would have helped audiences understand the faults of the game. The audience of the review wants to know both the positives and negatives of the game so that they can decide whether or not they want to buy them game after watched an unbiased review. However, the reviewer of this game enjoyed everything so couldn't provide any negative aspects of the game which would have benefited the viewer.

The Verdict
Collin Moriarty said that "The Last of Us is a masterpiece," and that it provided one of the most rememberable, heart-felt and brutal adventures gaming experiences that he has ever played. He said that its graphics make it brilliant despite its raw, brutal and hopeless theme. He would recommend the game to anyone and has provided the game with a 10/10 for its amazing story, great character representation, superb gameplay and immersive elements.


Far Cry 4

Reviewers Impression
The reviewer, Mitch Dyer (from IGN), enjoyed the size of the open world and the signature combination of open world and flexible first-person-shooter tactics. As a player he enjoyed the gameplay mechanics as he travelled through the open world and completed all of the extra missions and found the collectable items hidden throughout the game. However, he didn't enjoy the narrative of the game, because he felt that the characters and missions were unexplained in areas, with some incredibly exiting parts along the way.

Suggestions for Improvements
Mitch Dyer suggested that the game needed to explain where the character were in parts of the narrative. He said that some characters completely disappear from parts of the story and are not mentioned, while the antagonist of the game is not the main focus and barely appears in the story.

The Verdict
Overall he gave Far Cry 4 an 8.5/10 because it had visual variety, tons of individual challenges and side quests for the player to complete and a dense world with enough options to give the player something they want to complete all the time. However, he said that the characters in the game were weak and made the narrative disappointing, which is what kept the game from reaching a higher score.

No comments:

Post a Comment